Profile
Legal Structure
Mehmooda Maqbool Mills Limited (‘Mehmooda Maqbool’
or ‘the Company’) was incorporated on August 30, 1968. as a public unlisted company under
the Companies Act, 1913 (now the Companies Act, 2017). It was listed on the
Karachi Stock Exchange in 1968 and subsequently delisted later on.
Background
The
company’s two edible
oil extraction units started operations in 2002 that have been engaged in crushing variety
of edible oilseeds.
The Company procures Cotton seed, Rapeseed,
and Sunflower seed from local suppliers. For edible oil extraction, the Company majorly imports non-GMO Canola from Australia and non-GMO Soybean from Africa.
The operations of both units depend upon the availability of the oilseeds
and demand for edible oil. The Company
has also installed
a Ghee and Cooking oil and flour unit as well.
Operations
Solvent extraction units have a combined installed
capacity of 400MT/day. Oil refining unit has an installed capacity
of 72MT/day. Whereas,
the flour mill has
total installed capacity
of 240MT/day. The Ghee & Cooking Oil Unit has a
total combined production capacity of 100MT/day. The Company’s manufacturing facility and Head Office are
located at 2-Industrial Estate, Multan.
Ownership
Ownership Structure
Mehmooda Maqbool Mills Limited,
a fully owned enterprise of the Maqbool Group, is primarily owned by the sponsoring family, who holds a
significant ownership stake.
Stability
The ownership structure of the Company is notably stable, as it is entirely held by the sponsoring family. This consolidated ownership framework minimizes the potential for conflicts and ensures unified decision-making. With all shares vested within the family, the Company benefits from a cohesive vision and a strong commitment to its long-term growth and sustainability.
Business Acumen
The Maqbool Group, founded by a respected business family of Multan, has established a significant presence in the region. Beyond its ownership of Mehmooda Maqbool Mills, the group also maintains notable interests in the textile sector, demonstrating a diversified portfolio within key industries of the local economy. This diversification underscores the family's commitment to the region's economic development. Mr. Bakhtawar, a seasoned businessman and member of the Maqbool family, has recently been elected as the Chairman of the Multan Chamber of Commerce. This appointment highlights his recognized leadership within the business community and further strengthens the family's ties to the local economy. His role as Chairman of the Chamber of Commerce positions him to advocate for business interests, promote economic growth in the region, and potentially create synergistic opportunities for the Maqbool Group's various ventures. It also suggests a deep understanding of the local business landscape and a commitment to its advancement.
Financial Strength
Mehmooda Maqbool Mills Ltd. benefits from the financial strength of its parent company, Mehmood Textile Mills, a prominent player in the textile industry. This affiliation with Mehmood Textile Mills, allows the Company to leverage the resources and expertise of a larger and established group. This relationship likely contributes to the company's financial stability and ability to pursue growth opportunities.
Governance
Board Structure
Board comprises of seven
members at present, two executive
and five non-executive directors. All the members are from the sponsoring family.
Members’ Profile
All
the BoDs are experienced individuals. The Board’s Chairman,
Mian Tanvir Ahmad Sheikh, is associated with Mehmooda Maqbool Mills Ltd. and
Maqbool Group since inception and has more than four decades of business
experience.
Board Effectiveness
The Directors are actively involved in the management of the Company to oversee and manage the Company's operations, ensuring direct involvement in strategic and operational decision-making. However, the Board does not currently have any sub-committees in place to provide specialized support or assistance in governance or management functions.
Financial Transparency
The Company’s external auditors, Shinewing
Hameed Chaudhri and Co. Chartered
Accountants, have expressed
unqualified opinion about the
financial statements of FY24. Company’s auditors have been QCR rated by ICAP
and are also in category ‘B’ of SBP’s panel
Management
Organizational Structure
Mehmooda Maqbool Mills Ltd. operates through three functional departments: Sales & Marketing, Procurement & Production, and Finance & Administration. Each department is headed by a dedicated director, ensuring focused management and clear accountability within these key areas of the business.
Management Team
The
Company’s CEO Mian Bakhtawar Tanvir Sheikh, has an overall working experience
of more than 13 years. He has been associated
with the Company since inception. Mr. Bakhtawar, a seasoned businessman and member of the Maqbool family, has recently been elected as the Chairman of the Multan Chamber of Commerce. This appointment highlights his recognized leadership within the business community and further strengthens the family's ties to the local economy. His role as Chairman of the Chamber of Commerce positions him to advocate for business interests, promote economic growth in the region, and potentially create synergistic opportunities for the Maqbool Group's various ventures. It also suggests a deep understanding of the local business landscape and a commitment to its advancement.
Effectiveness
The effectiveness and efficiency of Mehmooda Maqbool Mills' management team are enhanced through the timely and relevant information provided by its management information system (MIS). A well-functioning MIS plays a crucial role in supporting informed decision-making at all levels of the organization. The management structure currently lacks effectiveness due to the absence of formal management committees. This gap presents an opportunity for improvement, as the establishment of such committees could provide specialized oversight, streamline decision-making processes, and enhance overall governance. By implementing these committees, the Company could achieve more efficient management and better alignment with strategic goals.
MIS
Mehmooda Maqbool Mills Ltd. utilizes an Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system, a comprehensive software solution that integrates various business processes and data into a unified system. This ERP system likely manages core functions such as finance, manufacturing, sales, and human resources. While the ERP system serves as the central repository for business data, the company's internal dissemination of information takes a more tailored approach. Instead of relying solely on direct access to the ERP system for all employees, the company documents information and generates reports "as per requirement." This suggests a controlled and selective distribution of information.
Control Environment
Mehmooda Maqbool Mills Ltd. conducts regular internal reviews to assess and oversee the effectiveness of its operational controls. These reviews are a critical component of internal governance and risk management, designed to ensure that the company's processes and procedures are functioning as intended.
Business Risk
Industry Dynamics
Edible
oil is one of the highest imported commodities in Pakistan. During the year,
2.717 million tonnes
of edible oil (including oil extracted from imported oilseed) of value Rs 794
billion was imported. Local
edible oil production remains at 0.471 million tonnes. In line with population
growth, edible oil demand
is forecast to grow about 5% and palm oil imports grew accordingly, reaching
3.6mln tons in FY24.
The price of Soybean oilseed stood at 479 USD/MT in Jun-24 as compared to 591
USD/MT in the
comparative year, showcasing a decrease of ~18%. On the other hand, the price
of palm oil stood at
873 USD/MT in Jun-24 and 816 USD/MT in Jun-23, which is forecasted to ease
further. Comparatively
reductions in selling prices have impacted the revenues substantially for the
refineries. Due to the rise
in input costs, especially raw material cost, many companies have experienced a
reduction in their profit
margins and faced working capital shortages. With expectations for better
cottonseed production, Total
oilseed production in 2024/25 is projected to decrease marginally to 3.43
million tons, due to an
expected minor decline in cottonseed production, and no growth in rapeseed and
sunflower seed output.
The industry's future outlook is developing due to price volatility and PKR
depreciation.
Relative Position
Considering the revenue generated within the edible oil industry in Pakistan, the Company holds a substantial market share. Similarly, the Company has also achieved a significant market share in the flour market.
Revenues
The Company, focused on
local sales, generated revenue from three core product categories: ghee &
cooking oil (38%), flour (27%), and meal (35%).In FY24, the Company achieved a
top-line revenue of PKR 13 billion, compared to PKR 10 billion in FY23. This
represents a substantial 26% year-on-year growth in sales. The primary driver
of this growth was the significant increase in flour sales, which rose from PKR
179 million in FY23 to PKR 3.6 billion in FY24. This highlights the Company's
successful expansion in the flour segment.
Margins
The Company's gross profit
margin saw improvement in FY24, rising to 10.6% from 9.2% in FY23. This
positive change can be attributed to the increased sales volume, primarily
driven by the strong performance of the flour segment. The higher sales volume
likely allowed the company to absorb fixed costs more effectively, contributing
to the improved gross margin.
Operating profit margin
also demonstrated growth, reaching 8.8% in FY24 compared to 7.3% in the
previous fiscal year. This indicates improved operational efficiency and cost
management, likely influenced by the increased sales and potentially better
control over operating expenses.
However, despite
improvements in gross and operating margins, the Company experienced a decline
in net profit margin. It decreased significantly to 0.8% in FY24 from 7.0% in
FY23. This deterioration is primarily attributed to elevated finance costs,
which offset the gains achieved in gross and operating profitability.
Sustainability
Over the period, the company has diversified its
manufacturing, producing meal as a by-product of edible oil extraction and flour, which
has a stable national demand.
Financial Risk
Working capital
The
Company's inventory management showed slight improvement in FY24, with average
inventory days decreasing to 32 days from 36 days in FY23. This suggests
potentially more efficient inventory turnover and a reduced risk of
obsolescence.
However,
there was a slight deterioration in the management of trade receivables, with
average collection days increasing marginally to 68 days in FY24 from 67 days
in FY23. This indicates that the Company took slightly longer to collect
payments from its customers. While the change is small, it bears monitoring to
ensure it doesn't represent a trend.
Overall
gross working capital days improved slightly, decreasing to 100 days in FY24
from 102 days in FY23. This positive change reflects the combined impact of
improved inventory management offsetting the slight increase in receivable
days.
The Company
experienced a deterioration in managing its trade payables, with payable days
decreasing to 10 days in FY24 from 7 days in FY23. This suggests the Company
paid its suppliers more quickly. While paying suppliers promptly can be
beneficial for maintaining good relationships, excessively short payable days
could impact cash flow.
Net working
capital days, which represents the overall time it takes to convert current
assets into cash, improved to 90 days in FY24 from 95 days in FY23. This is a
positive indicator, suggesting enhanced efficiency in the Company's cash
conversion cycle, driven primarily by improvements in inventory management.
Coverages
The Debt Coverage Ratio analysis provides valuable
insight into the company’s capacity to meet its debt obligations through its
Free Cash Flow to Operations (FCFO), reflecting its financial stability and
creditworthiness. In FY24, the Company's FCFO increased to PKR 887 million,
compared to PKR 634 million in FY23. This is a positive development, indicating
improved cash generation from core operations. However, despite the increased
FCFO, the Company's finance costs also rose significantly to PKR 606 million in
FY24 from PKR 369 million in FY23. Consequently, the Company's debt
coverage ratios decreased. The FCFO coverage ratio declined to 1.5x in FY24
from 1.7x in FY23. This indicates a slightly reduced capacity to cover finance
costs with operating cash flow.
Similarly, the total debt coverage ratio also decreased
to 1.4x in FY24 from 1.6x in FY23, reflecting a similar trend in the overall
ability to service all debt obligations. While the coverage ratios remain above
1.0x, the downward trend warrants attention and suggests that the Company's
increased debt load is impacting its debt servicing capacity.
Capitalization
The
Capitalization Ratio analysis evaluates the proportion of a company’s capital
structure financed through debt, offering insights into its long-term financial
leverage and risk profile. The Company's capital structure appears
to be highly leveraged. This signifies a reliance on debt financing, which can
amplify both profits and losses.
In FY24, the
Company's total borrowings amounted to PKR 2.6 billion, a decrease from PKR 3.3
billion in FY23. While the reduction in overall debt is a positive sign, the
composition of the debt raises concerns.
A significant
94% of the Company's borrowings are short-term. This heavy reliance on
short-term debt can create refinancing risk, as the Company will need to
regularly roll over these obligations. This exposes the company to fluctuations
in interest rates and the availability of credit, potentially impacting its
financial stability. While the total debt has decreased, the high proportion of
short-term debt suggests the company's financial risk remains elevated.
|